Understanding weld discontinuities

THE FABRICATOR® MAY 2003

June 12, 2003

By:

A welder's primary concern in any kind of work is ensuring his weld is sound. For this reason, it's important for an inspector examining the weld to be able to spot a variety of weld discontinuities, including:

  1. Porosity.
  2. Incomplete fusion.
  3. Incomplete joint penetration.
  4. Unacceptable weld profiles.
  5. Cracking.

The first step toward understanding weld discontinuities is to examine some welding terminology.

Discontinuityis defined as an interruption of the typical structure of a material, such as a lack of homogeneity in its mechanical, metallurgical, or physical characteristics. A discontinuity could be the result of a defect, but isn't necessarily a defect.

A defect, on the other hand, is a discontinuity that by nature or accumulated effect (for example, total crack length) renders a part or product unable to meet minimum applicable acceptance standards or specifications. A defect results in rejection of the part or product.

Because we're examining these phenomena outside the requirements of specific welding codes or standards and don't discuss their limitations in terms of these documents, we'll use the word discontinuities to describe them.The first type of weld discontinuity we'll address is porosity.

Porosity

Porosity is defined as a cavity-type discontinuity formed by gas entrapment during solidification. These trapped gases in the molten weld may form bubbles or pockets as the weld solidifies.

The four main reasons for the presence of gases that cause porosity are:

  1. Dirty base material contaminated with hydrocarbons such as oil, grease, or paint.
  2. Moisture on the joint surface or electrode in the form of water or hydrated oxides or water leaks from poorly maintained cooling systems that can introduce hydrogen into the welding process.
  3. Insufficient or improper shielding caused by an inadequate shielding gas flow rate; gas that's contaminated from its source or from its delivery system; or wind or draft that prevents the gas from adequately protecting the molten weld metal.
  4. Incorrect welding conditions or techniques.
  5. Porosity often is classified by its shape and distribution within the weld, such as uniformly or randomly scattered, cluster, or linear. Each of these porosity distributions may have different levels of acceptance within a welding code or standard.

The most practical methods for controlling or eliminating porosity are to use clean base materials, properly store uncontaminated welding consumables, adequately maintain welding equipment, use proven welding procedures, and weld in acceptable environmental conditions.

Incomplete Fusion and Incomplete Joint Penetration

Because these terms are sometimes misused, it's important to understand the difference between these two weld discontinuities.

Incomplete fusionis a weld discontinuity in which fusion doesn't occur between the weld metal and fusion faces or adjoining weld beads. This absence of fusion can occur at any location within the weld joint and be present in fillet welds or groove welds.

Incomplete fusion may result when the temperature of the base material or previously deposited weld metal is not elevated to its melting point during the welding process. Incomplete fusion often is found on one leg of a fillet weld and is caused by an incorrect welding angle, which distributes heat nonuniformly between both sides of the joint.

It also may be caused by oxides or other foreign material on the surface of the base material.

Incomplete joint penetrationis a discontinuity in a groove weld in which the weld metal doesn't extend through the joint thickness. It's the failure of the filler metal or base metal to fill the root of the weld completely.

Some common causes of incomplete joint penetration are a bad groove weld design or a fit-up that is unsuitable for the welding conditions. Incomplete joint penetration can occur if the root face dimensions are too large, the root opening is too small, or the included angle of a V-groove weld is too narrow. All of these joint design problems restrict the weld's ability to penetrate the joint's thickness.

Incomplete joint penetration can be prevented with the correct joint design and fit-up in accordance with welding procedure requirements.

Understanding these weld discontinuities will help welding inspectors identify them and, more important, prevent them from occurring in production. Using welding inspection as a preventive tool within the quality system is more efficient than using it only as an appraisal technique to sort bad welds from good welds.

Unacceptable Weld Profiles

The profile of a completed weld may have a considerable effect on the performance of that weld in service. Welding inspectors must identify discontinuities through visual inspection and evaluate their acceptance or rejection according to the applicable welding code or standard acceptance criteria.

Unacceptable weld profilescan cause a reduction in base material thickness, reduction in weld size, or stress concentrations on the weld or plate surface. These types of weld discontinuities often seriously detract from the overall performance of a welded component in service.

Some weld profile discontinuities are undercut, overlap, insufficient throat, and excessive convexity.Undercut. Undercut is defined as a groove melted into the base metal adjacent the weld toe, or weld root, and left unfilled by weld metal.

The term undercutdescribes two specific conditions. The first is the melting away of the base material at the side wall of a groove weld at the edge of a bead, which produces a sharp recess in the side wall in the area where the next bead is to be deposited. This type of undercut can entrap inclusions within the recess, which then may be covered by a subsequent weld bead.

This condition usually can be corrected by grinding down the recess before depositing the next bead. If the undercut is slight, however, an experienced welder who knows how deep the arc will penetrate may not need to remove it. Undercut of the side wall of a groove weld won't affect the completed weld if the condition is corrected before the next bead is deposited.

The second condition is reduction of the base metal's thickness at the line where the weld bead on the final layer of weld metal ties into the surface of the base metal. This position is known as the toe of the weld. This condition can occur on a fillet weld or a butt joint.

The amount of undercut permitted at the surface of the completed weld usually is specified within the welding code or standard being used. The maximum permissible undercut requirements for completed welds should be followed stringently, because excessive undercut can seriously affect the performance of a weld, particularly if it's subjected to fatigue loading in service.

Both types of undercut usually are caused by an incorrect welding technique, incorrect electrode positioning, or incorrect travel speed. High currents and a long arc increase the probability of undercut.

Overlap. Overlap is defined as a protrusion of weld metal beyond the weld toe, or weld root. This condition occurs in fillet welds and butt joints and produces notches at the toe of the weld that are undesirable because of their resultant stress concentration under load. This discontinuity can be caused by incorrect welding techniques or insufficient current.

Insufficient Throat. Insufficient throat usually occurs in fillet weld and butt joint profiles that are concave. Excess concavity reduces throat thickness, which considerably reduces weld strength. This condition usually is caused by excessive welding current or arc lengths.

Excessive Convexity. Excessive convexity can produce a notch effect in the welded area and, consequently, concentration of stress under load. For this reason, some codes and standards specify the maximum permissible convexity of a weld profile. Insufficient current or incorrect welding techniques typically cause this condition.

Cracking

Cracks in a weldment are probably the most dreaded of all the weld discontinuities. Because so many materials and applications are used in welding, cracking is a complex subject.

The base material's crack sensitivity may be associated with its chemistry and its susceptibility to the formation of elements that reduce its ductility. Excessive stresses in the weld joint, particularly if the material is in a crack-sensitive condition, can cause cracking to occur.

The welding operation itself can produce stresses in and around the weld, introducing extreme localized heating, expansion, and contraction.

Cracking often is caused by stress concentration near discontinuities in welds and base metal and near mechanical notches in the weldment design. Hydrogen embrittlement, a condition that causes a loss of ductility and exists in weld metal because of hydrogen absorption, can contribute to crack formation in some materials.

Hot and Cold Cracks. Cracks are classified as one of two types: hot or cold.

Hot cracks develop at elevated temperatures, propagate between the grains of a material, and commonly form during solidification of weld metal.

Cold cracks develop after solidification of the weld, as a result of stresses, and propagate both between grains and through grains. Cold cracks in steel sometimes are called delayed cracks and often are associated with hydrogen embrittlement.

Hot cracks and cold cracks can be further categorized as base material cracks and weld metal cracks.

Base Material Cracks. Heat-affected zone (HAZ) cracking most often occurs with base material that can be hardened. High hardness and low ductility in a HAZ often are the result of a metallurgical response to welding thermal cycles. In ferritic steels, hardness increases and ductility decreases with an increase in carbon content and a faster cooling rate.

The HAZ hardness depends on the base material's ability to be hardened, which in turn depends on the base material's chemical composition. Carbon has a predominant effect on steel's hardenability. For instance, cast iron contains between 2 and 4.5 percent carbon, which gives the alloy high hardness and low ductility. Welding this material without seriously considering cooling rates and residual stress invariably will result in base material cracking.

Weld Metal Cracks. Weld metal cracks can be divided into three types:

  1. Transverse, which are perpendicular to the direction of the weld.
  2. Longitudinal, which travel in the same direction as the weld and often are confined to the center of the weld. This type of crack may be an extension of a crack that originally initiated at the end of a weld.
  3. Crater, which can be formed by an abrupt weld termination if a crater is left unfilled with weld metal. These cracks usually are star-shaped and initially extend only to the edge of the crater. However, they can propagate into longitudinal weld cracks.

Dealing With Cracks. Cracks are unacceptable discontinuities and are detrimental to weld performance. A crack, by its nature, is sharp at its extremities, so it acts as a stress concentration. The stress concentration effect of a crack is greater than that of most other discontinuities.

Cracks have a tendency to propagate, contributing to weld failure under stress. Regardless of their size, cracks aren't permitted in weldments governed by most fabrication codes. They must be removed by grinding or gouging, and the excavation filled with sound weld metal.

Successful welding procedures incorporate the controls that are necessary to overcome the tendency for crack formation. Such controls are preheating temperature, interpass temperature, consumable type and preparation, and postweld heat treatment.

Welding inspectors are responsible for evaluating these procedural controls during inspections to ensure welding is performed to minimize the possibility of weld cracking.

Detecting and Evaluating Discontinuities

Weld discontinuities often are detected through visual inspection. Some are detected with inspection methods, such as radiography, ultrasonics, liquid penetrant, and magnetic particle inspection.

The maximum acceptable limitations for these discontinuities depend on the performance requirements of the welded component and are specified in the appropriate welding code, standard, or specification. The welding inspector often is required to determine the extent of discontinuities and to establish their acceptance or rejection based on the relevant acceptance criteria.

Tony Anderson is technical services manager with AlcoTec Wire Corp., 2750 Aero Park Drive, Traverse City, MI 49686-9263, 800-228-0750, fax 231-941-9154, tanderson@alcotec.com, www.alcotec.com. AlcoTec Wire Corp. is a producer of aluminum welding wire.



Tony Anderson

CEng
ESAB Welding & Cutting Products
411 S. Ebenezer Road
Florence, SC 29501
Phone: 800-372-2123
Fax: 231-941-9154
Tony has a background as a certified welding inspector, welding engineer-quality manager, and NDT manager. He also serves as chairman of The Aluminum Association Technical Advisory Panel for Welding and Joining, vice chairman of the AWS D1G Subcommittee 7 on Welded Aluminum Structures, and a member of Practical Welding Today's Editorial Review Committee.

More in Testing and Measuring from TheFabricator.com

Published In...

The Fabricator®

The FABRICATOR® is North America's leading magazine for the metal forming and fabricating industry. The magazine delivers the news, technical articles, and case histories that enable fabricators to do their jobs more efficiently. The FABRICATOR has served the industry since 1971. Print subscriptions are free to qualified persons in North America involved in metal forming and fabricating.

Preview the Digital Edition

Subscribe to The Fabricator®

Read more from this issue

comments powered by Disqus