22 possible causes of weld metal porosity
Take a look at gas flow, material conditions, and consumables to prevent this defect
November 1, 2010
Porosity is a weld defect that is fairly common, but also fairly easy to fix. What issues contribute to weld porosity? This checklist gives a welder a good idea of what might be causing the problem.
Round holes in the weld bead are a sign of a defect called weld metal porosity. Photo courtesy of Bernard.
Weld metal porosity is not a welcome sight in a weld bead, but it shows up all too often.
Porosity is weld metal contamination in the form of a trapped gas. Shielding gases or gases released as a result of the torch being applied to treated metal are absorbed into the molten metal and released as solidification takes place. In other instances, the shielding gas doesn’t completely reach the weld pool and the atmospheric air adversely affects the weld bead.
Evidence of porosity comes in the shape of rounded holes, called spherical porosity (see Figure 1). If the holes are elongated, the defect might be called wormholes or piping.
Because porosity has acceptable levels, it is infrequently considered a serious defect. However, depending on the welding code or standard, porosity might be cause for a weld reject.
Luckily, porosity is a defect that has an approximate 90 percent prevention rate. With a few tips for identifying possible causes of the porosity, a welder quickly can turn reject parts into weldments that are acceptable under most welding codes.
Possible Porosity-related Problems
From most common to least, let’s look at some of the causes of porosity in welds:
- The cylinder is out of gas. This happens quite often.
- Air or a draft of some kind disturbs the delivery of the shielding gas during the welding process. Overhead or floor fans even as far as 25 feet away can wreak havoc on the gas delivery. Welders also need to be aware of open doors and air being discharged from machinery. These drafts, if more than 4 to 5 miles per hour, can affect shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) and
flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) operations.
- The presence of moisture can lead to problems. It might be simple water or morning dew, but also could be condensation from welding on heavy plate and lap joints, which might occur particularly when temperatures reach below 50 degrees F. The easy fix is to preheat the metal to 200 to 220 degrees F to evaporate the moisture.
- Plugged or restricted gas metal arc welding (GMAW) gun nozzles—typically from weld spatter—impede the delivery of shielding gas. To rectify this obstacle, the welder needs to look at the nozzle opening before starting a weld. This double-check might prevent weld spatter from falling into the weld.
- The weld nozzle is held too far away from the weld puddle. The volume of shielding gas reaching the weld is diminished, and dilution of the shielding gas with the atmosphere severely affects the weld.
- The GMAW gun is laid at an angle that will spread the gas flow out and actually suck in the atmosphere from the back side, opposite the nozzle direction. A 5- to 15-degree angle, perpendicular to the joint, is an acceptable angle for forehand or backhand methods with GMAW or FCAW guns and SMAW electrodes.
- Paint, grease, oil, glue, and sweat release large volumes of gas when exposed to arc welding temperatures. This is especially true with solid-wire GMAW and gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW), but FCAW and SMAW processes are vulnerable as well. The flux makeup was not designed to handle such contamination.
- When mill scale and rust are welded over, decomposition gases are formed, and oxidation begins, which can involve the presence of moisture. The strong possibility of cold lapping and lack of fusion at the weld toe also exists. When a metal oxidizes, it is no longer truly a metal and can’t be expected to respond to welding the same as a metal, especially when welding flux is
- Plating compounds with zinc, such as in the galvanization process, can create a problem. Zinc melts at approximately 420 degrees F. At welding temperatures far in excess of 2,000 degrees F, zinc changes from a solid to a gas in a fraction of a second. Also, zinc dust is a byproduct of the welding process. The release of both gases and dust make welding galvanized metal an
unpleasant experience. (In an effort to prevent letters and calls of protest, let me say electrodes and welding procedures have been developed to weld galvanized material successfully. However, training and lots of practice are absolutely necessary to overcome the presence of all that trapped gas.)
- SMAW electrodes, FCAW electrodes, and submerged arc welding (SAW) flux absorb moisture in an unprotected environment. To address moisture in the welding process, codes are pretty clear about the use of dryers and ovens to store these materials. SAW flux in particular is like a sponge. Once the container is opened, the welder should store the package according to the
- The gas flow is too high. Gas flow of 50 to 60 cubic feet per hour (CFH) at the GMAW nozzle and 20 to 30 CFH at the GTAW torch should be plenty. If not, ask why. Wide-open gas flow at the nozzle actually creates turbulence and can pull outside air into the weld zone. Additionally, it’s a terrible waste of gas and adds unnecessary cost to the project. The only exception might
be if the shielding gas contains more than 50 percent helium.
- A pinched or smashed gas hose doesn’t deliver the shielding gas properly. If the gas hose is more than 20 ft. long, the possibility of it kinking is pretty good.
- Improper use of antispatter compounds, sprays, or gels can be a major contributor to porosity. When used in excess, the antispatter material becomes a contaminant, boiling into a gas when exposed to the high temperatures of the welding arc. Also, jamming the GMAW gun into a container of antispatter gel can result in the gel dripping back into the weld puddle. An operator
should use the anti- spatter material properly or not at all.
- Weld filler metals contaminated with paint, grease, oil, tape, and glue can release gases when exposed to the very hot welding arc. Even dirty gloves used during GTAW can contaminate the consumables. Cleaning solid wire and flux-cored wire with wire wipes and GTAW fillers with steel wool is a good idea.
- Contaminated GMAW gun liners can introduce unwanted elements to the weld pool. All the grease, oil, dust, and dirt found in the shop environment collects on the wire and ends up in the gun’s whip liner. Stainless steel and high-nickel-alloy wires are especially susceptible to attracting these contaminants.
- GMAW right on the edge of an outside corner joint might create problems given the awkward position of the nozzle. The nozzle often does not cover the joint properly, causes turbulence, and draws in outside air into the weld joint.
- If the weld joint is open at the root, it will suck in air from the back side. Unprotected liquid metal can absorb air easily.
- The welding gas itself could be contaminated. If the welding gas is a suspect, the shop needs the gas supplier to certify that the gas has the correct dew point.
- A contaminated gas hose could be a culprit, in particular, hoses that have been used for other activities prior to being used in a welding application. In one real-world example, a hose was grabbed from a storeroom to repair a cut hose that was attached to the wire feeder. Unfortunately, a bug had built a nest in the hose while it was sitting undisturbed in the storeroom. In
another example, an air hose that was previously used as an air line for a tool on a line with an oil lube system on it was quickly connected to welding equipment only to find out later that the hose was full of air tool oil.
- Damaged O-ring seals on the GMAW gun whip where it plugs into the wire feeder or the GTAW torch cap where it screws into the torch could introduce unwanted air into the welding process.
- Cut or burnt hose anywhere from the regulator flowmeter to the connection at the feeder could create issues.
- A defective gas solenoid at the wire feeder or the GTAW machine is a possible contributor to conditions that create porosity.
Looking at the Welding Procedure
From a procedural point of view, a welder should keep these two scenarios in mind:
- When beginning a weld in a tight corner, an operator will need more than the little burst of shielding gas than is released at the start of the weld. That little burst is seldom enough to purge out the corner pocket before the weld puddle starts.
- The purge of the gas line after a break or lunch period often results in a shield gas-free start. The welder should pull the trigger for a second or two, cut off the wire, and go.
Welders working with high-strength, low-alloy steels, such as A514, A588, and A709, should be aware of porosity caused by the release of hydrogen. That gas gets trapped in the steel during solidification and can lead to hydrogen-induced cracking. These cracks develop as time goes on, and catastrophic failure occurs when metal fatigue reaches a certain level.
Obviously, all of the 22 possible causes of weld metal porosity won’t apply when it comes to defect investigation. However, it might make sense to take steps to address the most common possible causes.
Checking for system leaks is easy. At the start of the day, the welder should open the cylinder handwheel, pressurize the system for 15 to 20 seconds, turn the cylinder off, and watch the regulator dial. If the dial stays put, the welder is ready to ignite the arc. If it starts to coast down in approximately one or two minutes, a leak is present somewhere, and the welder needs to find it.
Another thing worth mentioning is that the type or position of the porosity is often a key to what is causing it. A copy of AWS B1.11, “Guide for the Visual Examination of Welds,“ explains in detail what the probable cause is for the porosity.